Theatre in Review

Displaying items by tag: Mean Girls

This new staging of Mean Girls the Musical, now playing at Paramount Theatre in Aurora’s downtown theatre district, brings Tina Fey’s sharp, culturally defining high-school satire to the stage with a pop-infused score and a contemporary theatrical energy that reframes the familiar story for a new generation - and they do a pretty fetch job with it. What this production captures especially well is the all-too-well-known rush of being thrown back into the fiercely competitive atmosphere of high school all over again - the crowded hallways, the shifting alliances, the way a single rumor can tilt the entire school social landscape. The staging at Paramount Theatre makes those dynamics feel immediate, almost uncomfortably recognizable, reminding audiences how quickly the desire to fit in can override better judgment. It’s funny, sharp, and just self-aware enough to let you laugh at the chaos while remembering exactly what it felt like to navigate it.

The plot follows Cady Heron (Elizabeth Stenholt), a teenager who moves from Kenya to suburban Chicago and enters North Shore High School after years of being homeschooled. She quickly discovers that the school operates on a rigid social hierarchy, narrated with biting humor by Janis Sarkisian (Lucy Godínez) and Damian Hubbard (Steven Klenk), who guide her through the cliques and warn her about the most powerful group: The Plastics. Regina George (Dariana Mullen), Gretchen Wieners (Angel Alzeidan), and Karen Smith (Julia Hope Budd) rule the school with a mix of charm, intimidation, and ruthless social strategy, and when Regina unexpectedly invites Cady into their circle, she is pulled into a world of manipulation, gossip, and carefully curated popularity. Janis, who has a long-standing feud with Regina, convinces Cady to infiltrate The Plastics and report back on their behavior, setting off a chain of choices that gradually erode Cady’s sense of self as she begins adopting Regina’s tactics and losing sight of her own values.

Paramount’s “Plastics” are played by (from left) Julia Hope Budd as Karen Smith, Dariana Mullen as Regina George and Angel Alzeidan as Gretchen Wieners.

One of the production’s most “wow” moments comes when The Plastics first appear, silhouettes poised atop the school stairway before descending like rock stars - a clever, high-impact entrance that instantly sets the tone.

Central to the musical’s conflict is the Burn Book, a scrapbook created by The Plastics and filled with photos of classmates alongside handwritten insults, rumors, and secrets. It’s a private weapon of social destruction, and when Regina discovers Cady’s betrayal, she detonates it by releasing the book to the entire school, planting a fake insult about herself so she appears innocent. The fallout sparks a chaotic riot among the junior class, forcing Principal Duvall (Austin Nelson Jr.) to intervene and leading to a school-wide reckoning. 

Mean Girls taps into something painfully recognizable: the way girls learn to measure themselves against each other, and how the need to fit in can become its own quiet form of survival. It lays bare the unspoken rules of teenage girlhood - the constant self comparison, the social performance, the fear of exclusion - and shows how easily those pressures can harden into the very behaviors that hurt others. Beneath the comedy, there’s a clear understanding of how identity gets shaped, distorted, and reclaimed in the crucible of adolescence.

At the center of the production is Elizabeth Stenholt, whose performance as Cady Heron gives the show its emotional anchor. She charts Cady’s evolution with clarity, moving from wide-eyed newcomer to reluctant Plastic with a grounded, human touch. Opposite her, Dariana Mullen delivers a sharply etched Regina George, wielding charisma and calculated menace with effortless control. Together, Stenholt and Mullen create a dynamic push and pull that fuels the show’s momentum, supported by a leading cast whose charged performances keep the story vivid and unexpectedly heartfelt. Veronica Garza (Mrs. Heron / Ms. Norbury / Mrs. George) adds versatility and grounded humor across her roles, shifting smoothly between characters and giving each one a distinct presence; among the talented cast, she stood out as one of my favorites, especially in her turn as Regina’s humorously over-the-top “cool mom.”

Director Devon Hayakawa guides the production with a steady, clear approach, keeping the story moving and giving the cast room to shape their characters. Kasey Alfonso’s choreography brings consistent energy to the ensemble, supporting the humor and helping the larger numbers land with ease. Kory Danielson’s music direction and conducting provide a reliable foundation throughout, keeping the vocals tight and the orchestra responsive to the shifts in tone. The design team adds cohesive polish: Kotryna Hilko’s costumes are full of sexy punch and humorous excitement and Greg Hofmann’s lighting is an explosion of flashing pink tones that would delight any Mean Girls fan. Adam Rosenthal’s sound design maintains balance, Erin Pleake’s video work adds many layers of reality to the already aesthetically exciting set, and Ethan Deppe’s electronic elements blend smoothly into the score.

Cady (Elizabeth Stenholt, center), the new girl from Africa who transfers to Chicago’s North Shore High, is befriended by social outcasts Damian (Steven Klenk, left) and Janis (Lucy Godinez, right) in Mean Girls.

The set is impressively immense, a sprawling expanse of pink that never feels wasted or ornamental. Every nook and cranny is smartly utilized to build out North Shore High School, with stairways, hallways, classrooms, and common spaces folding into one another in ways that keep the action fluid and visually engaging.

The musical numbers are where this production really hits its stride, pairing Alfonso’s crisp, high-energy choreography with songs that sharpen the show’s humor and emotional stakes. I wasn’t necessarily expecting the music to land as strongly as it did, assuming the humor and engaging story would carry most of the weight, but the score proves to be one of the production’s biggest strengths. Elizabeth Stenholt shows she can truly belt, delivering powerhouse vocals in both “It Roars” and “I See Stars,” while Dariana Mullen matches her intensity and range with a commanding “World Burn.” Lucy Godínez gets a standout showcase of her own in “I’d Rather Be Me,” reinforcing why Janis Sarkisian remains such a fan favorite. Steven Klenk’s Damian - the “too gay to function” best friend - lands sharp comedic lines throughout and brings infectious energy to “Where Do You Belong?” The choreography makes clever use of the revolving floor and incorporates desks, lunch tables, and trays in ways that keep the staging inventive and visually playful. Comedy lands not just in the dialogue but in the musical staging itself - the heightened high-school dramatics, the sly visual gags, and the rhythmic timing that turns social chaos into full-company spectacle. The humor comes through clearly, supported by musical numbers that are confidently staged and consistently engaging.

Based on the now cult-favorite 2004 film, the musical premiered on Broadway in 2018, adapted once again by Tina Fey with music by Jeff Richmond and lyrics by Nell Benjamin. Its theatrical form allows the story to expand emotionally, using songs to deepen character motivations and give voice to internal conflicts that the film conveyed through montage or narration. While the musical retains the film’s core plot, several notable differences distinguish it from its 2004 source: updated characterizations, modernized humor, broader representation, a stronger presence of social media, and shifts in relationships and family dynamics that reflect contemporary storytelling.

Paramount’s production of Mean Girls the Musical proves to be a smart, engaging take on the material, carried by a committed cast and a creative team that understands how to translate the story’s humor and heart to the stage. It moves with confidence, lands its character beats cleanly, and offers enough freshness to make revisiting this world worthwhile. For audiences looking for a lively, contemporary musical with sharp performances and a cohesive design approach, Mean Girls is an easy recommendation - now running through October 11, 2026 at Paramount Theatre in Aurora.

https://paramountaurora.com/events/mean-girls/

Published in Theatre in Review

Break out your Burn Book and mark these dates: Aurora’s Paramount Theatre is launching its 15th Broadway Series with the Chicago-area premiere of Mean Girls, August 26-October 11, 2026. Opening Night is Friday, September 4 at 7 p.m.

Nominated for 12 Tony Awards, including Best Musical and Best Original Score, Mean Girls is the Broadway sensation that’s so fetch, it rules the school. 

Based on Tina Fey’s iconic Paramount Pictures film, Mean Girls is the story of Cady Heron, a sweet and smart new girl who’s just moved from Africa to Chicago’s North Shore. When she enters the wild world of North Shore High, she quickly finds herself tangled up with The Plastics, the school’s most popular - and ruthless - clique led by queen bee Regina George. As Cady tries to fit in, she learns that popularity comes with a price. And revenge can get ugly fast.  

With a book by Tina Fey, music by Jeff Richmond, and lyrics by Neil Benjamin, Mean Girls gets an A+ for big laughs, bold, campy style, unforgettable pop-rock songs, and a message that is surprisingly honest. It’s a fresh, colorful must-see for anyone who’s ever tried to find their place in the crowd. So grab your friends, wear pink (on Wednesdays, of course), and experience the non-stop, fun-loving musical that proves even the fiercest frenemies can find redemption.

Devon Hayakawa, after serving on the directing teams of South Pacific, Come From Away, Cats, and Disney’s Frozen, makes their Paramount solo directing debut with Mean Girls. Their top-tier creative team includes choreographer Kasey Alfonso (Come From Away, Jeff Award-winner, Cats), veteran Paramount Broadway Series music director and conductor Kory Danielson, set designer Milo Bue (Come From Away) and costume designer Kotryna Hilko (Peter and the Starcatcher). 

On stage, Cady Heron will be played by Elizabeth Stenholt, familiar to Paramount audiences as Olive in The 25th Anniversary Putnam County Spelling Bee (Jeff-nominated, Performer in a Supporting Role), Medium Alison in Fun Home (winner, Jeff Award, Performer in a Supporting Role), and Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz

Dariana Mullen, coming off The Great Gatsby at New York’s Broadway Theatre, makes her Chicago debut as Cady’s arch nemesis, Regina George. The cast also features Angel Alzeidan as Gretchen Wieners, Julia Hope Budd as Karen Smith, Diego Vazquez Gomez as Aaron Samuels, Lucy Godinez as Janis Sarkisian, Steven Klenk as Damian Hubbard, Ben Mathew as Kevin G, Veronica Garza as Mrs. Heron/Ms. Norbury/Mrs. George, and Austin Nelson Jr. as Principal Duvall. 

The ensemble includes Tola Abitogun, Jeremiah Alsop, Matty Bettencourt, Anna Louise Bramlett, Nicole DiSandro, Ben Dow, Tiyanna Gentry, Joshua Messmore, Hannah Remian, Nataki Rennie, Morgan Schoenecker, Jacob Simon, Abby C. Smith, Amanda Walker and Elaine Watson. 

Ticket information
 

Mean Girls begins previews Wednesday, August 26. Opening Night is Friday, September 4 at 7 p.m. Performances run through October 11: Wednesday at 1:30 p.m. and 7 p.m.; Thursday and Friday at 7 p.m.; Saturday at 2 p.m. and 7 p.m.; Sunday at 1 p.m. and 5:30 p.m. (Exception: No matinee Wednesday, August 26.) Single tickets to Mean Girls are $34-$109 when purchased in-person. Additional fees apply for phone and online orders.


Any Mathlete knows it’s smarter to save money with a Paramount Theatre 2026-27 Broadway Series subscription. Four-show packages start at just $73, including Mean Girls, a world premiere adaptation of The Christmas Carol (November 11, 2026–January 3, 2027), Stephen Sondheim and James Lapine’s Sunday in the Park with George (February 10–March 28, 2027) and an 80s-inspired Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat  (April 28-June 13, 2027).

That’s the same “Buy Two Shows, Get Two Shows Free” offer Paramount has offered since it launched its first Broadway Series in 2011, and has since grown to be the largest subscription theater in the U.S. Think of it as four Broadway-quality musicals for less than the price of one show downtown. Plus, Aurora boasts easy, affordable parking and a host of new restaurants all around. 


Paramount Theatre is located at 23 E. Galena Blvd. in downtown Aurora. For tickets or subscriptions, visit ParamountAurora.com, call (630) 896-6666, or stop by the Paramount box office Monday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m., and until show time on show days. For group discounts, contact Melissa Striedl, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or (630) 723-2461. 

Paramount: Making live theater accessible to all

Paramount will offer two Pay What You Can previews Thursday, August 27 at 7 p.m. and Saturday, August 29 at 2 p.m. See ParamountAurora.com/Pay-What-You-Can for details. 


Paramount will offer open captioning Wednesday, September 30 at 7 p.m. and American Sign Language interpretation Friday, October 9 at 7 p.m. 

Paramount offers free assistive listening devices  at all performances, including new Auracast technology that connects to blue tooth earphones. Check in at the coat room before the show to borrow a device. If you require wheelchair or special seating or other assistance, please contact the box office in advance at (630) 896-6666 or This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

Published in Now Playing

 

         20 Years and counting!

Register

     

Latest Articles

Does your theatre company want to connect with Buzz Center Stage or would you like to reach out and say "hello"? Message us through facebook or shoot us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

*This disclaimer informs readers that the views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author, and not necessarily to Buzz Center Stage. Buzz Center Stage is a non-profit, volunteer-based platform that enables, and encourages, staff members to post their own honest thoughts on a particular production.