What’s the line between faith and reason? That’s the question at the center of playwright John Pielmeier’s contemporary classic ‘Agnes of God’. The reliable ensemble at Redtwist Theatre creates an atmospheric production that leaves an indelible impression.
‘Agnes of God’ tells the story of a young, mentally impaired nun who is charged with infanticide after a strangled baby is found in her room. Inspired by a true story, Pielmeier digs deeper, past the tabloid shlock, and finds meaning in tragedy. Though nothing of divine intervention was determined in the real case, this play asks, what if there had been? Is the age of miracles definitively in the past?
In Pielmeier’s version, Agnes is written as a true innocent who the Mother Superior of the convent believes might really be talking to God. When atheist psychiatrist Dr. Livingstone is assigned by the court to evaluate Agnes’ mental health, her scientific certainties are put to the test.
The three-woman cast in director Clare Brennan’s production feature two Redtwist ensemble members: Jacqueline Grandt, Debra Rodkin, and regular player Soleil Perez in meaty roles. And the immersive black box performance space heightens the sense of intimacy to that of a confessional booth.
Jacqueline Grandt as Dr. Livingstone has several spans of direct conversation with the audience, as if she’s a lawyer giving her opening and closing statements. The uneasiness with which Dr. Livingstone’s conversations go with the Mother Superior (Debra Rodkin) are visually represented by one of the show’s minimal set pieces—a slanted desk. Through the frankincense fog, we see that Mother Superior might not be telling the entire truth. Soleil Perez plays a wild, and untamed Agnes whose stage presence makes you wonder if maybe she is a heretic after all.
Unique stage lighting and taught scenes give this production an edge. Jacqueline Grandt is captivating and her transformation from harsh chain-smoking criminal psychiatrist to vulnerable sceptic brings more nuance to the stage than perhaps what’s in the script. It’s on her performance this play really hinges. Grandt is an actress with confidence that she has the audience firmly in her grasp and this performance really showcases her range. She’s on stage for all two hours of the show’s running time and her intensity only builds from scene to scene.
Many contemporary writers in recent years have grappled with issues involving the Catholic church, John Patrick Shanley’s Broadway hit ‘Doubt’ comes to mind—but in that regard ‘Agnes of God’ was ahead of its time. Written in the late 70s, at a time where ‘The Exorcist’ had just electrified a mostly religious American audience a few years earlier, a film whose scares rely on an audience of believers. ‘Agnes of God’ tells a story of concealed abuse and religious conspiracy, in an era when people were less likely to question the church. Sadly, the more disturbing elements of the play remain as timely and relevant now as ever. However, scandals aside, what this play universally offers to both non-believers and believers alike is the opportunity to ask, can everything be answered by science and fact?
Through July 9 at Redtwist Theatre. 1044 Bryn Mawr Ave. http://www.redtwisttheatre.org
*Extended through July 16th
Chicago continues to produce some of the most exciting work in the country this Summer, offering a wide variety of plays…
Token Theatre, Chicago's Asian American theatre company, announces the company's first full production, ZAC EFRON, written by Artistic Director David Rhee, co-written by Managing…
I arrived at City Lit Theater’s MURDER IN THE CATHEDRAL expecting a heavy, serious, doubtless thought-provoking but rather intimidating major…
Porchlight Music Theatre is proud to announce the return of its free summer concert series Broadway in your Backyard, now in its…
Despite the fact that I have never read the Newberry Award-Winning children’s book called Last Stop on Market Street, I…
I’m amazed that it’s been 18 years or so since I first saw a Hell in a Handbag production. Though…
“Together we created this nothingness,” says Audrey Francis in Steppenwolf’s production of Larissa Fasthorse’s ‘The Thanksgiving Play’. Hot off its…
Bramble Theatre Company, is proud to announce the third annual Festival of Unfinished Work at the new Bramble Arts Loft located on the second…
Broadway In Chicago is excited to announce that individual tickets for the world premiere of the first ever touring production…
Chicago Shakespeare Theater presents The Enigmatist, an immersive and captivating experience of illusions, puzzles, and cryptology, written and performed by renowned magician…
Steep Theatre will be back on stage in 2024 with two new productions that continue the company's tradition of bringing…
In 1940, the 25-year-old Orson Welles, previously known as a stage and radio actor, had achieved widespread fame for his…
Fleetwood-Jourdain Theatre's 2024 season of four productions will open with the original musical 1619: THE JOURNEY OF A PEOPLE by Chicago writer…
Growing up our radio dial was tuned to one channel, K-Earth 101. In Southern California that station was the oldies,…
Crowds will flock to see “Judgment Day,” having its world premiere at Chicago Shakespeare Theater on Navy Pier. While many…
In "Panther in the Sky," playwright Lani T. Montreal masterfully weaves a tapestry of grief, resilience, and redemption through the…
A collaboration of Chicago dance and Germany lighting sculpture live on stage About the Program: This program, set within an…
Broadway In Chicago is excited to announce the pre-Broadway World Premiere of DEATH BECOMES HER is now playing at the Cadillac Palace Theatre…
Blue in the Right Way audaciously chose for their inaugural production a 400-year-old play, WOMEN BEWARE WOMEN, written in 1621…
I think my favorite thing – well, one of my favorite things – about Wyatt Kent’s take on HAMLET is…
Frolicking season is upon us once again and Joffrey Ballet welcomes summer with the return of Alexander Ekman’s “Midsummer Night’s…
As the audience takes its seats we are greeted by an atmosphere of foreboding, a trestle bridge girder to the…
Director Chuck Smith returns to Goodman with another major August Wilson revival–“Joe Turner’s Come and Gone”. This is the second…
The Gift Theatre is pleased to announce its 2024-25 season featuring Suzan-Lori Parks' masterpiece Topdog/Underdog directed by Shanésia Davis and the world premiere of Cygnus by Susan Soon He…
Broadway In Chicago is excited to announce that individual tickets for the world premiere of the first ever touring production…
Full cast and crew have been announced for BrightSide Theatre's upcoming production of JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR, the rock opera that…
Chicago Opera Theater (COT), Chicago’s foremost producer of new and reimagined opera, closes its 50th Anniversary season presenting the final performances of…
Tim Rhoze, Artistic Director of Fleetwood-Jourdain Theatre, has announced the company's 2024 season of four productions. The season will open with…
David Williamson, regarded as one of the top magicians in the world today, makes his Rhapsody Theater debut with Ridiculous! Known for his tours…
Curious Theatre Branch is pleased to announce the 35th annual Rhinoceros Theater Festival, May 25 - June 30 at six venues across Chicago. The…
Does your theatre company want to connect with Buzz Center Stage or would you like to reach out and say "hello"? Message us through facebook or shoot us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
*This disclaimer informs readers that the views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author, and not necessarily to Buzz Center Stage. Buzz Center Stage is a non-profit, volunteer-based platform that enables, and encourages, staff members to post their own honest thoughts on a particular production.