Theatre in Review

Displaying items by tag: Colton Sims

Marriott Theatre’s Heartbreak Hotel takes on the tricky task of charting Elvis Presley’s early ascent, walking the line between the mythic figure we think we know and the unpolished young man still figuring out who he was becoming. What emerges is a brisk, music‑driven portrait that leans into the volatility of those formative years - the industry pressures that boxed him in, the personal crossroads that pushed him forward, and the creative sparks that hinted at the cultural earthquake to come. It’s a show less interested in polishing the legend than in capturing the restless drive of a talent on the verge of rewriting American music.

Heartbreak Hotel traces Elvis Presley’s early rise with a pace that stays brisk without ever feeling hurried, using a clever device: a ’68 Comeback‑era Elvis looking back on his younger selves. At times the man, the teen, and the 11‑year‑old boy share the stage simultaneously - singing, reminiscing, harmonizing - embodying a life moving faster than any one version of him can fully grasp. The musical follows Elvis from the tentative spark of his Sun Studio sessions into the glare of national attention, tracing how each new opportunity brings both momentum and complication. Producers, handlers, and well‑meaning advisors orbit him constantly, each with a different vision of who he should become, and the show uses those interactions to underline just how precarious his initial ascent really was.

As the demands of fame tighten around him, the story frames Elvis’s evolution as a series of choices - some instinctive, some imposed, all shaping the performer he’s still learning to be. Rather than digging for psychological depth, the plot focuses on the push‑and‑pull between artistic hunger and commercial pressure, capturing the uneasy transition from raw talent to cultural commodity. It’s a portrait of a young man standing at the edge of a seismic career, long before the iconography calcifies and the legend overtakes the life.

At the center of Heartbreak Hotel is Tyler Hanes playing Elvis Presley, who carries the show with a mix of youthful swagger and genuine vulnerability. His performance hinges not just on vocal accuracy but on capturing the restless, slightly bewildered energy of a young man being swept into stardom. His renditions of “Blue Suede Shoes” and “Heartbreak Hotel” land with the right mix of polish and rawness, and his quieter moments - particularly the early Sun Studio sequences and those paired with Priscilla - give the production its emotional grounding.

The show’s Colonel Tom Parker, portrayed by Rob Lindley, is the necessary counterweight: charming, calculating, and always two steps ahead. Lindley brings a slick, almost Vaudevillian charisma that keeps the character from slipping into caricature (although Parker may have been a caricature of himself anyway). His scenes pop with tension, especially in numbers where he orchestrates Elvis’s next move with a smile that never quite reaches his eyes.

Tyler Hanes as Elvis Presley (center) with ensemble in Heartbreak Hotel at Marriott Theatre.

The Sun Studio ensemble - the musicians, producers, and collaborators - provide some of the production’s most engaging textures. Jackson Evans, as Sam Phillips, is heavily featured in the first act and delivers one of the show’s standout performances, offering a steady, clear‑eyed presence that anchors the opening chapters with real artistic purpose. The play digs into Phillips’s instinct for raw talent - his uncanny ability to spot greatness beforehand - and makes clear that his relentless championing of Elvis is what first carried the young singer’s sound across Memphis and into the broader South. His work with the band digs deep and gives us an idea of Phillips’s impact in shaping a new kind of rock ‘n’ roll sound. Their group numbers in the studio, including “That’s All Right,” have an infectious looseness that contrasts sharply with the more commercialized performances later in the show.

The supporting cast adds essential color. Colton Sims offers a sharp, unaffected turn as Teen Elvis, capturing the raw spark before the polish sets in, and Charles Adler Bischoof, as young Elvis, brings a bright, unguarded innocence that reminds the audience just how early the legend began.

Elizabeth Telford lends Gladys Presley a quiet emotional weight, centering the story whenever she’s onstage. Anna Louise Bramlett brings an earnest warmth to Dixie, while Amanda Walker gives Priscilla a steady, grounded presence that subtly deepens the story.

In one of Heartbreak’s most exciting moments, Alexandra Palkovic takes control of the stage delivering a sleek, charismatic jolt as Ann-Margret, hinting at the whirlwind to come. Palkovic dances with real fire, echoing Ann‑Margret’s signature style with crisp precision and an infectious burst of energy. Palkovic later joins Hanes in one of the most touching moments when the two perform a beautiful rendition together of “You’re the Boss.” The addition of a full Ann‑Margret song‑and‑dance number feels especially meaningful, since her on‑screen chemistry with Elvis has always struck me as one of the high points of his physical and emotional vitality.  

Tyler Hanes as Elvis Presley and Alexandra Palkovic as Ann-Margret.

Karl Hamilton gives Vernon Presley a quiet, understated presence, and Naiqui Macabroad stands out in his multi‑role track - Johnny Bragg, Chuck, Jackie Brenston, and the producer for both Steve Allen and Ed Sullivan - slipping between characters with crisp versatility and welcome bursts of personality. Fredrick Webb Jr. also makes a strong impression in multiple roles, notably as Roy Brown, Otis Redding, Fats Domino, and throughout the ensemble.

Going back to the musicians, the live band is one of the show’s more memorable assets. With Jake Busse as Bill Black, Zac Richey as Scotty Moore, and Trevor Lindley Craft as Ronnie (pre-DJ Fontana days) forming the tight onstage trio, the musicians anchor the production with a sound that feels both authentic and freshly charged. Lindley Craft doubles as Frank Sinatra. He and Hanes deliver one of the evening’s highlights as they recreate the famous duet from Elvis’s post‑Army appearance on The Frank Sinatra Show - a stylish medley of “Love Me Tender” and “Witchcraft” that lands with effortless charm.

Melanie Brezil also brings a radiant spark to Sister Rosetta Tharpe, delivering her featured moment with bright, joyful command on both vocals and guitar.  

Together, the band’s instrumental work and the ensemble’s rich harmonies elevate the musical landscape. A mid‑show gospel sequence of “Peace in the Valley” – another one of this staging’s big moments - showcases the ensemble’s vocal power and reminds the audience of the musical traditions that shaped Presley long before fame did.

Marriott’s in‑the‑round setup gives Heartbreak Hotel an expansive energy, with action unfolding on all sides. The cast’s aisle work draws the audience in, creating a surprisingly immersive sense of scale, and the smart use of media and projections amplifies that impact even further. A staging in this intimate space gives the storytelling room to gather real thrust. That quality becomes especially clear as the sequences build toward the emotional high point, when Elvis finally sheds the cookie‑cutter movie image he’d long outgrown and reclaims his artistry in the ’68 Comeback Special, reestablishing his place as the King of Rock ’n’ Roll. 

I’ve always been drawn to stories orbiting Elvis Presley, and Heartbreak Hotel earns its place among them by honoring the legend without embalming him in nostalgia. Elvis wasn’t just a chart‑topper; he was a cultural accelerant, the artist who fused gospel, blues, country, and rhythm‑and‑blues into a sound that detonated across America and permanently rewired its musical DNA. His influence stretched far beyond the stage - reshaping fashion, performance style, youth identity, and the very idea of what a pop star could be. Productions like this one matter because they keep that seismic legacy in motion, passing it from one generation to the next not as a museum relic, but as a living, breathing force that still shapes the music we hear today.

When referring to rock 'n' roll, John Lennon said it himself, “Before Elvis, there was nothing.” Heartbreak Hotel echoes that sentiment.

Directed and choreographed by Deidre Goodwin, this musical bears the imprint of an artist who understands how to propel a story without letting the spectacle swallow it. Her direction shapes the evening with a steady, purposeful rhythm, keeping the focus tight even as the musical numbers expand outward. Goodwin’s fantastic choreography blends period flavor with a clean, contemporary precision, giving the show a kinetic pulse that feels both rooted in its era and alive in the present. It’s her sense of balance - between nostalgia and freshness, between narrative drive and musical release - that ultimately gives the production its lift.

Elvis devotees will find plenty to appreciate in Heartbreak Hotel, which treats the King’s formative years and artistic rebirth with genuine affection and a clear understanding of his musical legacy. But the show’s appeal stretches well beyond Presley fandom; anyone who loves American music - from gospel and blues to early rock and soul - will recognize the joy in hearing these sounds brought to life by a superbly talented cast and band. Heartbreak Hotel runs through June 2nd at Marriott Theatre and is an exciting musical experience well worth attending. 

For tickets and/or more show information, click here

This review is proudly shared with our friends at www.TheatreInChicago.com

Published in Theatre in Review

Million Dollar Quartet Christmas brings the legends back together - Elvis Presley, Johnny Cash, Jerry Lee Lewis, and Carl Perkins - for a high-energy holiday jam at Sun Records in Memphis, Tennessee. Packed with rock 'n' roll hits and festive favorites, this jukebox musical delivers a nostalgic blast of seasonal cheer. Now staged in the round at Marriott Theatre, it’s a toe-tapping celebration you won’t want to miss.

This thrilling holiday musical whisks audiences back to December 4, 1956, inside Memphis’s iconic Sun Records studio, where the birth of rock ‘n’ roll gets a festive twist. Framed as a lively holiday reunion of Elvis Presley, Johnny Cash, Jerry Lee Lewis, and Carl Perkins, the show plays like a jukebox time capsule - glittering with tinsel, rhythm, and seasonal joy. The studio glows with holiday charm - garlands strung, mistletoe dangling, and a decorated tree tucked in the corner - as four rock ‘n’ roll legends reunite to trade stories, revisit Christmases past, and muse about the road ahead. Their banter is light, their bond electric with nostalgia, and every song reverberates with the unfiltered energy of icons at the height of their powers.

Framed as a rockin’ ride through Christmas past, present, and future, the show fuses tender reflections with turbo-charged takes on holiday favorites and golden-age rock hits. Each legend infuses the stage with their signature sound, transforming timeless tunes into pulse-pounding celebrations of the season - and the rebellious heart of rock ‘n’ roll.

Million Dollar Quartet Christmas at Marriott Theatre ignites the stage with a high-voltage blend of rock ‘n’ roll swagger and holiday spirit. Elvis Presley, Johnny Cash, Jerry Lee Lewis, and Carl Perkins deliver powerhouse performances that showcase their iconic styles while wrapping the season in nostalgic charm. Alongside the show’s signature hits, audiences are treated to festive favorites like “Blue Christmas,” “Santa Claus Is Back in Town,” “Boogie Woogie Santa Claus,” “Run, Rudolph, Run,” “God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen,” and a rollicking mashup of “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” and “Jingle Bell Rock.”

This cast doesn’t just shine - they explode off the stage. Million Dollar Quartet Christmas blazes to life with a powerhouse ensemble that doesn’t imitate rock ‘n’ roll royalty—they channel them. With razor-sharp musicianship, magnetic charisma, and a sleigh-load of seasonal swagger, these performers ignite a musical storm that’s both heartwarming and high-octane. It’s not just a performance - it’s a full-blown holiday revival of rhythm, soul, and rock ‘n’ roll cheer.

Let’s raise the curtain on this extraordinary cast - each performer a vital spark in the blazing brilliance of Million Dollar Quartet Christmas.

JP Coletta plays Jerry Lee Lewis and detonates onto the stage with a performance that’s equally volcanic and virtuosic. From the moment his fingers hit the keys, it’s clear we’re in for a wild ride: he attacks the piano with manic glee and devilish precision, channeling the raw, unfiltered spirit of rock’s original wild child. Every note ricochets with rebellion, every flourish drips with swagger, and every sideways grin feels like a wink to chaos itself. Coletta’s portrayal is a masterclass in musical mayhem - blistering, magnetic, and utterly irresistible. By the end, the piano’s smoking, the audience is beaming, and the ghost of Jerry Lee is surely somewhere backstage, grinning in approval.

As Carl Perkins, Trevor Lindley Craft brings a cool, soulful swagger, anchoring the show with crisp guitar licks and vocals laced with rockabilly grit. He’s the ensemble’s steady heartbeat - cutting through the chaos with finesse, style, and a quiet confidence that keeps the rhythm grounded. Whether trading riffs or harmonizing with the quartet, Craft exudes the kind of understated charisma that lets the music speak volumes.

Michael D. Potter steps into Johnny Cash’s boots with quiet power and commanding presence. His voice rolls in low and steady, like distant thunder on a Tennessee night, and his portrayal hums with authenticity. Potter doesn’t overplay the legend - he funnels him, letting the stillness between notes carry as much weight as the music itself. Stoic yet stirring, he draws the audience in with a magnetic gravity that feels both timeless and true.

Colton Sims doesn’t just impersonate Elvis Presley - he inhabits him with velvet vocals and hip-shaking bravado along with a gaze that could melt vinyl. From his first entrance, Sims radiates the kind of stage command that made Elvis a cultural phenomenon. His voice smolders, his movements sizzle, and his charisma is pure dynamite. It’s a performance that balances swagger with sincerity, capturing the King in all his electrifying glory.

As Elvis’ girlfriend Dyanne, Teah Kiang Mirabelli is a revelation. She infuses the stage with elegance, wit, and vocal brilliance, elevating every scene she’s in. More than just a supporting role, Mirabelli brings emotional depth and radiant charm, offering a counterpoint to the testosterone-fueled jam session. Her solos soar with precision and passion, and her presence adds a layer of warmth and complexity that rounds out the show’s dynamic pulse. Mirabelli is especially adorable during her cute, mandolin-playing Hawaiian themed number “Mele Kalikimaka”.

Ross Griffin grounds the show with quiet intensity as Sam Phillips, the visionary behind the music and the man holding the emotional reins. His performance is taut, urgent, and deeply human - a portrait of ambition, loyalty, and the weight of legacy. Griffin narrates the story; he lives in its tension, embodying a producer torn between past glories and future dreams.

Rounding out the ensemble with flair and finesse are Jed Feder as Fluke and Cody Siragusa as Brother Jay. With razor-sharp timing, rhythmic fire, and a dash of comic mischief, they keep the backbeat tight and the energy sky-high. Whether laying down grooves or landing punchlines, they’re the unsung heroes who make the whole jam session sing.

Together, this cast absolutely ignites. Every note, every gesture, every glance is charged with passion, precision, and holiday joy. It’s a Christmas musical miracle wrapped in tinsel and rock 'n' roll. The actors’ live musical performances - executed with impressive skill - infuse the production with an electrifying energy. With guitars in hand, a stand-up bass thumping, and drums driving the rhythm, the stage often pulses with the raw excitement of a live concert.

Under the spirited direction of Scott Weinstein, this holiday edition of Million Dollar Quartet strikes a joyful chord between festive fun and nostalgic reverence. Weinstein orchestrates the production with a keen sense of pacing and emotional texture, allowing the show to glide effortlessly from quiet, intimate moments to full-throttle rock ’n’ roll revelry. Whether it’s a tender ballad shared under the glow of Christmas lights or a raucous jam session that rattles the rafters, each scene is staged with precision, heart, and a wink of holiday mischief. The result is a dynamic, feel-good celebration that honors the legends of Sun Records while wrapping the audience in the warm glow of seasonal spirit.

Before the curtain rises, treat yourself to a festive feast at Embers Christmas Grille, the seasonal pop-up nestled inside the Lincolnshire Marriott Resort - just steps from the theater. Offered Wednesday through Friday, this holiday dining experience features a three-course prix fixe menu for $49 per person, served with a generous helping of cheer. Each dish is playfully named and thoughtfully crafted, blending seasonal inspiration with upscale comfort. With options spanning beef, chicken, and fish, the menu offers a whimsical twist on traditional holiday fare - perfect for theatergoers looking to savor the spirit of the season in style.

Million Dollar Quartet Christmas is holiday fun at its fullest.

Highly recommended.

For tickets and/or more show information, visit https://www.marriotttheatre.com/show/million-dollar-quartet-christmas.  

Published in Theatre in Review

 

         20 Years and counting!

Register

     

Latest Articles

Does your theatre company want to connect with Buzz Center Stage or would you like to reach out and say "hello"? Message us through facebook or shoot us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

*This disclaimer informs readers that the views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author, and not necessarily to Buzz Center Stage. Buzz Center Stage is a non-profit, volunteer-based platform that enables, and encourages, staff members to post their own honest thoughts on a particular production.