Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest is one of the greatest farces ever written. His wordplay caricatured high society, and clever pay-offs are hilarious when executed properly. The play was first performed on February 14, 1895 (Valentine's Day). The premiere took place at the historic St James's Theatre in London. Wilde famously subtitled the work “A Trivial Comedy for Serious People,” a reminder that its brilliance lies in treating absurdity with absolute sincerity. Unfortunately, No Dogs in the Kitchen Theatre Company’s recent production, directed by Genevieve Corkery, misses the mark when bringing this beloved play to the stage.
For those unfamiliar, the classic comedy follows two high-society bachelors, Jack Worthing and Algernon Moncrieff, who invent secret personas to escape the boredom of everyday life. Trouble arises, however, when Jack (going by the name of “Ernest”) proposes to Gwendolen, who is intent on only marrying a man with that specific name. Matters are complicated further when the carefree, mischievous Algernon also dons the moniker “Ernest” to woo Jack’s ward, Cecily, who shares the exact same romantic obsession with the name. To find happiness, the lovers must quickly untangle a web of ridiculous misunderstandings and mistaken identities. The true brilliance of Wilde’s script lies in its wordplay and sharp societal satire, taking the audience on a wild, hysterical ride where the utterly absurd is treated with the utmost importance.
Founded in 2023, No Dogs in the Kitchen is still a young company, and a certain learning curve is both natural and expected as they continue shaping their artistic identity. Their past work has already shown a clear interest in bold, unconventional staging, often embracing heightened physicality and playful absurdism. That adventurous spirit is a defining part of their aesthetic, and it’s evident the ensemble values experimentation and a willingness to push familiar texts in unexpected directions. While this production didn’t always find harmony between those impulses and Wilde’s finely tuned verbal wit, the company’s enthusiasm, imaginative framework, growing technical confidence, and emerging vision suggest they have the tools to grow into a distinctive and compelling presence within Chicago’s storefront theatre scene.
The cast of No Dogs in the Kitchen’s “The Importance of Being Earnest” at Facility Theatre.Photo: Alex Albrecht
That said, where this production struggles is in its apparent distrust of the script, adding jumbled and superfluous elements that only serve to undercut the humor it tries so hard to generate. It is as if the creative team didn't believe the script was funny enough on its own, choosing instead to pile on unnecessary subtext that needlessly deviated from - and was unsupported by - Wilde’s text.
This staging regularly undermines its own comedic timing with added, cartoonish sound effects that reduce wit to silly gags. From boinging springs to breaking plates, it felt as if someone was trying to use every button on a soundboard. Furthermore, a heavy hand of physical humor frequently distracts from the brilliant dialogue. During several monologues, cast members distracted the audience with routines like fighting on a sofa. Another oddity occurred in the final act when multiple cast members broke the fourth wall to deliver lines - a trick they hadn't used up until that point. It’s unclear why there was such distrust in the source material, and why a surplus of additions was believed to be the solution.
The performances also suffered from this same directive, often relying on over-the-top delivery. Mitch Karmis, who played two different butlers, mugged for the audience and utilized an almost cartoon-like physicality. David Lovejoy portrayed Lady Bracknell as a Mommie Dearest caricature instead of the formidable, sophisticated society matriarch who delivers scathing lines with dry, icy wit. The performance moved between widely contrasting vocal registers, creating an uneven tone that often felt out of step with Lady Bracknell’s traditionally controlled presence. It was also unclear why, in the final act, Lady Bracknell suddenly transformed into a flirtatious aggressor who growled at Jack and threw herself at the butler. Another odd decision was to have Dr. Chasuble played by Sara Corkery in a rubber race mask.
Amidst these choices, there was a bright spot in Garret Weigel’s Jack. For the most part, Weigel found the right balance between inventive character choices and a respect for the script. Jack could easily be played as a boring straight-man when up against the whimsical Algernon, but Weigel added a distinct flair to his interpretation without straying too far from the original play.
It is genuinely unfortunate that the production chose to deviate so drastically from the text. When done faithfully, The Importance of Being Earnest is a true theatrical gem. While there were moments that elicited genuine laughter, they occurred when the text was allowed to speak for itself, rather than being buried under extraneous gags.
While this hyper-stylized, over-the-top version might appeal to theatergoers seeking a radical, alternative spin on a classic, those looking for a faithful, witty adaptation of Wilde’s masterpiece will likely find this production is not the one.
The Importance of Being Earnest runs through July 26th at Facility Theatre. For more information and/or tickets, visit https://nodogsinthekitchen.org/.
