After many years without seeing the movie or reading the story of Peter Pan, the moment I learned that Peter Pan: The Hit Broadway Musical was coming to Chicago, my inner child couldn’t contain its excitement. I arrived at the James M. Nederlander Theatre, quickly found my seat, and noticed joyful children surrounding me. The adults were definitely outnumbered, but hey, we are still kids at heart and have imagination, too! As expected, on opening night, the theater was filled to capacity, and excitement was palpable.
As the lights dim, theatregoers are welcomed into the shared childhood bedroom of Wendy, John, and Michael. Their parents, preparing for an event that evening, are putting the kids to sleep as they prepare to leave. As soon as the parents are gone, Wendy is woken up to Peter Pan and Tinkerbell rummaging through the bedroom. Wendy confronts Peter, and he explains he’s looking for his lost shadow. Wendy helps him reclaim his shadow, and in the process, wakes up her brothers, John and Michael. One thing leads to another, and before you know it, Peter is sprinkling a bunch of fairy dust on the children. They take flight, and with a magical poof, they soar out of the window, embarking on their journey to Neverland. Sounds familiar, doesn’t it?
While the plot of the show shares similarities with the movie, it also introduces its own unique twists. Notably, a conflict arises between Tiger Lily’s tribe and Peter Pan along with the Lost Boys. The ongoing battle involves accusations of theft between the groups. Surprisingly, once Captain Hook enters the scene, Tiger Lily’s Tribe and the Lost Boys decide to form an unlikely alliance and become best friends.
The unification of Tiger Lily’s tribe and Peter Pan and the Lost Boys is, in my opinion, the best scene in the play. This performance is packed with ambient singing and beautifully choreographed dance. The musical number called “Friends Forever” plays as they dance along and try to find a new handshake to seal their newly established bond. The song boasts a wonderful melody, seamlessly intertwining with the joyous celebration.
The cast of Peter Pan is wonderfully diverse, featuring actors from various racial backgrounds. This production breathes new life into the story, making it feel more inclusive and significantly more multicultural than the original 1953 animated movie. Every actor delivers an outstanding performance, with special recognition for the young Reed Epley, who has captivated audiences on stage since the tender age of four.
Captain Hook, played by Cody Garcia, is excellent. Garcia is everything you could ask for in an antagonist. He is funny, sassy, and downright evil. Throughout the show, we watch him sing and dance his way into wicked plots to kill all of the children. Surprisingly dark for a kids’ show, I must say. Every time Hook is on stage the crowd laughs, captured by his beguilement. He has what sounds like a Scottish pirate accent and owns it with every word. Garcia’s singing is also impressive with a surprising vocal range that has depth and great heights.
Nolan Almeida, portraying Peter Pan, showcases remarkable acting skills. His singing, dancing, and ability to charm the audience with magic are truly fascinating. Almeida flawlessly hits all his cues and fully embraces his character throughout the show.
My only disappointment stemmed from the choice for the character of Tinker Bell. Anticipating the fairy in physical form, I was surprised when the show opted for what appeared to be a flashlight’s glow instead. Despite my reservations, the children in the audience adored the fairy light, with some even declaring Tinker Bell as their favorite character.
The live orchestra is phenomenal. Their music does a wonderful job complementing the show with whimsical sounds and adventurous beats. Each song is sweetly crafted to help tell the story of Peter Pan, the Lost Boys, and the children versus the dreaded Captain Hook. The music by Morris (Moose) Charlap is perfect and brings the show to life.
Beyond the enchanting music, the choreography by Lorin Latarro truly captivates the audience. Every dance, intricately woven into the musical numbers, is a resounding success, executed flawlessly by the talented cast. The exhilarating flips and graceful couple dancing add an extra layer of excitement. Amidst the choreography, the simulated fights between characters during the show provide an entertaining spectacle. And let’s not forget the magical flying sequences, seamlessly orchestrated by Paul Rubin, which transport us into the heart of Neverland.
Costume design emerged as one of my favorite aspects of the show. Anticipating a vibrant array of colors, I was not disappointed. Sarafina Bush, the costume designer, delivers costumes that are not only true to each character but are also bursting with life. Tiger Lily’s group sports a unique tribal look, while the Lost Boys’ attire exudes wildness and adventure.
The set and stage design further enhances the experience. The lush green jungle landscape of Neverland and the cozy children’s bedroom stand out as exceptional set pieces. Each set was thoughtfully interactive, seamlessly accommodating every scene. And within the Nederlander Theatre, the ambiance feels like the perfect gateway to Neverland—just a sprinkle of fairy dust and a glimpse through French casement windows, and you’ll be soaring.
Kudos to director Lonny Price and executive producer Trinity Wheeler for breathing new life into Peter Pan. Their fresh adaptation transports the beloved characters into a modern world, embracing the timeless magic of imagination. Whether you’re a first-timer or a seasoned viewer, this show promises fun for all.
After the show, I chatted with a few audience members to gauge their thoughts on Peter Pan. Cindy exclaimed, “The show was fantastic, and they had a thrilling cast.”
Kelly, on the other hand, shared a different perspective: “It was a great show, but this wasn’t the same Peter Pan I remember from my childhood. It feels like I didn’t recall any of this happening.”
And then there was Steven, brimming with excitement: “This show was fabulous! It’s a classic story with a modern twist—an absolute must-see for all ages.”
In summary, I thoroughly enjoyed the show. Peter Pan: The Hit Broadway Musical rekindled my youthful spirit and left me wistful for the days of unbridled imagination. While the entire performance was entertaining, Act Two held a special place in my heart. My inner child reveled in the magic, and I departed with renewed inspiration to seek out more ways to stay forever young.
Catch Broadway in Chicago's Peter Pan is being performed March 26th through April 7th at James M. Nederlander Theatre. Performances are Tuesday through Thursday at 7:00 p.m. (with a Wednesday matinee at 1:00 p.m. on April 3rd), Fridays at 7:30 p.m., Saturdays at 2:00 p.m. and 7:30 p.m., and Sundays at 1:00 p.m. (with an additional performance on Sunday, March 31st at 6:30 p.m.).
The run time of the show is about two hours with a short 15-minute intermission. Make sure to arrive early as the line outside of the theatre is likely to be buzzing with anticipation.
